Research Urges Excise Tax Repeal for Electrical Trucking Takeoff

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

Repeal of the federal excise tax (FET) on heavy-duty industrial automobiles needs to be a key device in the US’ push to cut back trucking’s greenhouse fuel emissions by means of electrification, based on a examine by a nonprofit that searches for options to environmental and power issues.

The report by Assets for the Future lays out the choices for speedier widespread electrification of trucking, and its findings again trade calls for of current months, together with from American Trucking Associations.

Launched Could 3, the report argues eradicating the excise tax on medium- and heavy-duty electrical vans (MHDEVs) can scale back the acquisition value, and that might be a part of the long-term resolution to lowering trucking and the general transportation sector’s emissions.

At present, Inner Income Code Part 4051 imposes a 12% federal excise tax on the primary retail sale of a truck. The heavy-duty excise tax was established in 1917 to defray the prices of World Conflict I. On condition that MHDEVs value greater than diesel automobiles, this excise tax will increase the overall tax burden for MHDEV purchases, the examine discovered.

An April 18 Senate Surroundings and Public Works Subcommittee on the way forward for clear automobiles noticed ATA First Vice Chair Andrew Boyle — co-president of Billerica, Mass.-based Boyle Transportation — testify {that a} new, clean-diesel longhaul tractor sometimes prices within the vary of $180,000 to $200,000. A comparable battery-electric tractor prices upward of $480,000, he mentioned.

Assets for the Future’s researchers mentioned that to place it in perspective, the $40,000 buy incentive accessible for MHDEVs by means of the Inflation Discount Act of 2022 — one of many key instruments within the Biden-Harris administration’s push to combat local weather change and scale back emissions — would cowl solely the excise tax on some very giant vans. An exemption on federal excise taxes for MHDEVs can thus assist scale back the value differential with diesel automobiles and make buy incentives simpler, they mentioned.

Decreasing the price to enter and diversify merchandise also can encourage competitors, thus limiting producers’ market energy and lowering the upfront buy worth of the automobiles, they added.

Repealing the tax would make a “fairly large monetary distinction,” Assets for the Future Transportation Program Director Beia Spiller instructed Transport Subjects, noting how giant an funding an electrical truck could be for smaller fleets.

There’s broad help within the trucking trade for the FET repeal. In February, a coalition of trade teams comprising ATA, American Truck Sellers (ATD) and Zero Emission Transportation Affiliation despatched a letter to congressional leaders pushing for the repeal.

“We want new and extra environmentally pleasant vans deployed on our roadways,” Scott McCandless, ATD chairman and president of Aurora, Colo.-based McCandless Truck Heart, mentioned in an e mail.

The #InflationReductionAct incentivizes the adoption of medium- and heavy-duty #electrical automobiles 🚚 ⚡️ —however there are bumps within the highway to widespread use. 🛣️@RFF Fellow @starbeia discusses these challenges and potential options within the newest installment of In Focus. ⬇️ pic.twitter.com/9FEENDDngU

— Assets for the Future (@rff) Could 11, 2023

“Half of the Class 8 vans on the highway are over 10 years previous and lack the cleaner applied sciences and gasoline effectivity positive factors of in the present day’s new vans. The FET is a barrier to our nationwide purpose to place extra cleaner-emission vans in service. For electrical vans, the FET is a counterproductive lifeless weight.”

In the meantime, Nationwide Non-public Truck Council Basic Counsel Rick Schweitzer instructed Transport Subjects: “NPTC helps repeal of the 12% FET and, if essential, changing the misplaced income into the Freeway Belief Fund with a pay-as-you-go tax akin to a gasoline tax or mileage-based person charge. As ATA and different repeal proponents have mentioned, the fee of 12% upfront on newly bought or leased automobiles is a disincentive to carriers investing in newer, safer, extra environment friendly and cleaner tools.”

“Particularly now that the acknowledged goal of the federal authorities is to encourage fleets to transition to cleaner tools, this tax undermines the Biden administration coverage supporting the usage of decrease emission automobiles,” Schweitzer added.

Progress has been made within the committee rooms and corridors of Congress following the decision to motion, stakeholders say. “ATA has seen actual progress in advancing a full repeal of this World Conflict I-era tax,” mentioned Jacqueline Gelb, the commerce group’s vp of power and environmental affairs.

“Now we have lawmakers from each events in each Home and Senate speaking in regards to the intensive advantages of repealing the FET — notably as a cheap mechanism to lowering the price of newer, safer, extra fuel-efficient automobiles to attain emissions reductions sooner — and never requiring the necessity to offset the comparatively small quantity of income eliminating this tax would value,” Gelb added.

Within the 117th Congress (2021-22), Sens. Todd Younger (R-Ind.) and Ben Cardin (D-Md.), and Reps. Doug LaMalfa (R-Calif.) and Chris Pappas (D-N.H.) launched the Trendy, Clear and Secure Vans Act (HR 8116/S. 2435) to repeal the tax.

Pappas and LaMalfa reintroduced the invoice within the Home on March 8. Younger and Cardin did the identical within the Senate.

Some trade teams have qualms in regards to the repeal although, looking for a extra nuanced strategy. Proprietor-Operator Unbiased Drivers Affiliation spokesman George O’Connor mentioned in an e mail that the commerce affiliation would help repeal of the FET if it had been clearer how the misplaced income for the Freeway Belief Fund would get replaced. The fund funds most federal authorities spending for highways and mass transit.

“The priority right here is, in the event you repeal the FET, it can primarily allow giant carriers to buy new vans at decrease value. Undecided it strikes a lot of our guys into the brand new truck market. But when the [Highway Trust Fund] backfill is industrywide, it creates a situation the place small trucking companies are paying extra taxes to subsidize company motor carriers’ buy of latest automobiles that in flip put the smaller guys at a aggressive drawback,” O’Connor mentioned.

Spiller sees focused subsidies for smaller fleets as the best resolution to that downside. She mentioned there have to be thresholds in place to ensure smaller fleets get their share of the broader pot, as an alternative of massive fleets gobbling up the funds on provide shortly.

Small fleets have much less entry to funding than their bigger rivals, so it is more difficult for them to shift to new know-how, Spiller mentioned. On prime of that, the manpower and hours within the day required to handle the method — from buying, to infrastructure coordination, to photo voltaic and battery storage add-ons that elevate long-term income and efficiencies — is usually briefly provide at such firms, she mentioned.